02 Layer 2 · Motive
Should you buy?
At 1.4–2% gross yields, this is a consumption decision before it is an investment one.
The short answer
Run the arithmetic before the emotion. In the major cities gross yields run 1.4–2%, round-trip transaction costs run 8–11%, and a holding period under five years usually costs more than it returns. If you expect to leave within three years, rent.
Layer 1 asked whether you may buy. This layer asks whether you should, and it is the one people skip — because it is the only layer where the answer is "no" for reasons that feel like caution rather than fact.
The arithmetic nobody runs
Four numbers decide most cases.
Gross yield. Annual rent divided by purchase price. In Shanghai, Beijing and Shenzhen it sits around 1.4–1.9%. In tier-two cities it reaches 2.0–3.4%. Compare that with your mortgage rate, currently in the low 3s for a first home, and the gap is not small.
Round-trip cost. Deed tax, commission, notarisation on the way in; VAT, income tax and commission on the way out. Call it 8–11% depending on how long you hold and whether the seller's taxes migrate to you.
Holding period. A 9% round trip over three years is 3% a year before you have paid a single management fee. Over ten years it is 0.9% a year. The same cost, divided by a different number of years.
The alternative. What else would the money be doing? If it would sit in a deposit account at 1.5%, the comparison is generous to property. If it would be in a global equity portfolio, it is not.
Four questions that settle it
- How many years will I actually live in this city? Write a number, not a feeling.
- If I had to sell in year three, what would the round trip cost me?
- If I rented an equivalent home instead, what would my net worth be in year five?
- Am I buying a home, or buying relief from the fear of missing out?
Question 3 is the one to actually calculate, and the rent versus buy tool exists for it. Question 4 is the one people answer dishonestly.
The table
| Your situation | Position | Why |
|---|---|---|
| In China ≤ 3 years | Rent | Round-trip cost exceeds plausible gain |
| 4–6 years, certain to occupy | Buy is defensible | Treat as consumption with a residual value |
| 7+ years, family stable | Buy is reasonable | Costs amortise; use value is real |
| Primary goal is appreciation | Don't | The yield arithmetic does not support it |
| You need liquidity within a year | Don't | The buyer pool is small and slow |
| You would buy a unit you would not live in | Don't | You are speculating with a residential permit |
Rule of thumb
A home you will live in for a decade is a legitimate purchase even at a 1.6% yield. A home you will live in for eighteen months is not a purchase at all — it is a very expensive rental with a large deposit.
What "buying as consumption" means in practice
Once you accept the apartment is not an investment, the criteria change in useful ways:
- Building quality and management matter more than appreciation. You will live with the lifts, the insulation and the property manager.
- Layout beats location premium at the margin. A well-planned 110m² in a decent district usually serves a family better than a cramped 95m² in a fashionable one.
- Renovation cost becomes part of the purchase price. Budget ¥3,000–8,000/m² for anything older than fifteen years.
- Exit still matters, just less. You may sell in ten years, and the buyer then will care about the land term, the building age and the management — the same things you should care about now.
The three numbers people get wrong
They use asking rent instead of achieved rent. A unit advertised at ¥14,000 a month may transact at ¥11,500 after two months vacant. Two months of vacancy on a 1.7% gross yield takes it to 1.4%.
They forget the recurring costs. Management fee at ¥8/m² on 120m² is ¥11,520 a year. Heating in the north adds another ¥3,000. On ¥220,000 of annual rent, that is a seventh of the income before any vacancy.
They assume the mortgage is the cost of the money. A 3.2% mortgage on a 1.6% yielding asset has a negative carry of 1.6% a year on the borrowed amount, before principal. That is not an argument against buying a home; it is an argument against calling it an investment.
When to stop
- Your horizon is under five years — stop
- You cannot describe the exit buyer — stop
- The yield is under 1.5% and you are borrowing — stop
- You are buying because a colleague did — stop
- You would not live in the unit yourself — stop
- You cannot afford a 10% price decline without changing your plans — stop
If you have made it through this layer with a real number and a real horizon, the next question finally becomes interesting: which city. That is layer 3.
Keep reading
Guides that support layer 2
Mortgages for foreign buyers: who lends, and on what terms
A narrower menu than citizens get — fewer banks, 50–60% loan-to-value, and stricter income evidence. What to prepare, and what to ask before you sign.
Read the guideProperty tax: what is actually in force, and where
Two pilot cities, a 1986 statute aimed at businesses, and a national residential tax that has been discussed for a decade. What an owner actually pays.
Read the guideThe full cost of buying: the 3–6% nobody budgets for
Deed tax, agency commission, notarisation, registration, and the seller-side taxes that get pushed onto buyers. A worked example on a ¥10M apartment.
Read the guide